LashStash by Sephora Review

Every Christmas I look forward to receiving the LashStash, a “multibranded mascara sampler set with eight small mascaras and two full sized mascaras” by Sephora. I tried out each mascara over the course of a few weeks and definitely have my faves (and my least faves)! I don’t normally post many beauty posts, but I thought it would be fun to share the results from each mascara as well as my thoughts on them. In case you want to try out the LashStash for yourself, here’s the link: https://rstyle.me/n/dejbu9cczfx

BTW! I did not curl my lashes before using any of these.

LashStash by Sephora

Dior Lash Primer

For $29.50, you can get the Dior Lash Primer at Sephora. I tried this one day when using an older mascara and really liked it. It definitely added length and volume to my lashes – and I did feel that the mascara stayed on longer. I did not wear this while trying the other mascaras, to make sure that I was testing out how long each of them stayed on without a primer.

Marc Jacobs – Velvet Noir

I’ve always felt that Marc Jacobs has good makeup products and was impressed with this mascara! It definitely added length and made my lashes more dramatic.

Too Faced – Better Than Sex

One of my favorites from the past few years. It creates full, voluminous lashes. My only complaint is that it gets flaky throughout the day and can be messy!

Milk – Kush

First time trying a Milk product and I really liked it! I do think this one looked better in person than in the photo. It added a lot of length and stayed the same throughout the day.

Smashbox –  SuperFan Fanned Out

Didn’t love this one, but didn’t hate it either. I didn’t feel that it added much volume, but it didn’t clump my lashes together – which seems to be one of the things most people love about it!

Hourglass – Caution Extreme Lash

Least favorite! The picture may look decent, but it took a lot of layers to get it to this. It almost felt dried out. Wouldn’t use again!

Benefit – Bad Gal

I liked the thickness of this one, but wasn’t a fan of the length. I didn’t feel that it added any length to my lashes!

Sephora – LashCraft

Definitely my favorite! It added length and volume and stayed on all day. It was also very easy to apply.

Urban Decay – Perversion

Loved this one! I will definitely be using this in the future. It stayed on throughout the entire day and made my lashes feel & look great.

Lancome – Mascara

Hated this one! I felt like my lashes clumped together and looked stringy. Added a little bit of length, but will not be using this one again.

I hope you enjoyed this post! Let me know if you want to see more beauty content on my blog.

Thanks for reading!
Much love,


Shop The Post

Tell Me What You Think! leave a comment...

  1. It’s so helpful to actually see a comparison post like this! Its one thing to hear about a good mascara, but ive always liked seeing them side by side with other options to see how they compare!